skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Maddie (?) Was wonderful & the kid who sang and played sax was awesome!
Debbie Scholz via google.com - Jun 20, 2021
Great place.. outdoor dining with a nice view.
Matthew Brent-Manderick via google.com - Jun 14, 2021
I'm sincerely impressed with our brunch food! Not only is it fantastic that Matt & Tony's has FREE P
I'm sincerely impressed with our brunch food! Not only is it fantastic that Matt & Tony's has FREE PARKING, but my Prime Rib Hash brunch entree was excellent; seriously, excellent! I'm gonna zero in on the shining star, first: The dish comes with probably the best "smashed" fingerling potatoes I've ever had. The paprika seasoning mes ... read more
Gwen W. via yelp.com - Jun 11, 2021
Visited here for a casual birthday dinner last Saturday evening with family and had a wonderful experience. We arrived early and were seated right away, which was a good thing because it looked like the restaurant got busy closer to 6:30/7 PM. The servers were very nice, and the owner stopped by to check on us too. The food and 2 dri ... read more
Nick Stover via google.com - Jun 7, 2021
Tim is an awesome bartender who makes everyone feel welcome and comfortable. Meghan was our server this evening and she went above and beyond to make sure it was a great experience. Give these 2 a raise! Good help is hard to find.
R. Shane Hampton via google.com - Jun 3, 2021
The best homemade cheese sticks.
Becky Harrison via google.com - May 31, 2021
Was in the mood for something different, and found Matt & Tony's on doordash. Was a little nervous, but delightfully pleased with our choice. Husband had the new your strip, and I had the chicken strip, both were very pleasing and large portions. Thank you ... read more
Tammy Hillman via google.com - May 29, 2021
Food was just good, not great. That said, I'll give them that 5th star because apparently their bartender is psychic and she knows what you want about 30-60 seconds before you do.
Matthew Harnish via google.com - May 27, 2021
Very good dinner. The appetizers are delicious. The fried calamari stood out, very good. The soup of the day, a vegetable soup, was exceptional. The ribs were great. I hope to return soon. I'm looking forward to trying different items on the menu. Prices are reasonable.
Theodore Palmer via google.com - May 26, 2021
Had been seeing this place popup on Yelp and as the wife and I like to try new places we decided to
Had been seeing this place popup on Yelp and as the wife and I like to try new places we decided to drop in. We were impressed with the staff and the ambiance of the restaurant and the food was great. That prime rib was to die for. We will definitely be back again and again.
David G. via yelp.com - May 25, 2021
Ordered on Doordash and the driver took our food. They remade our food for us, gave us a dessert and wrote us a little apology note even though it wasn't their fault. I had their ribs and they really did fall off the bone. Great customer service, food and packaging 👌 ... read more
Wesley Meadows via google.com - May 24, 2021
My husband and I found this little spot we have never tried before and we were very impressed with the atmosphere, staff and food! We both got the full rack of ribs with Mac and cheese, I had the coleslaw and he had the mashed potatoes. Left full and happy 😃 ... read more
Jen Warnock via google.com - May 15, 2021
We often order Matt and Tony's delivery to our nightshift job! Our favorite is the Roasted Beet & Pe
We often order Matt and Tony's delivery to our nightshift job! Our favorite is the Roasted Beet & Pecan salad with the blackened salmon (getting extra of the sherry vinaigrette is a must)! Another fan favorite is the French dip sandwich!
Liana W. via yelp.com - May 5, 2021
Ordered take out tonight. Portions were huge and the flavor was amazing!! We don't order out much, so this made our day! Definitely would order again.
Wendy Finney via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
This place is amazing!
Jason Casillas via google.com - Apr 23, 2021
Great little hidden gem. Food and service were great definitely will be returning to try more.
Chauna M via google.com - Apr 18, 2021
Excellent food and service. Will definitely be back ... read more
Whitney Johns via google.com - Apr 18, 2021
Matt and Tony's was recommended to me by a friend, and my wife and I were not disappointed. We were
Matt and Tony's was recommended to me by a friend, and my wife and I were not disappointed. We were super impressed by the friendly and polite wait staff who clearly enjoyed what they were doing. The food was delicious and we will definitely be back!
Nick C. via yelp.com - Apr 18, 2021
Came across this place randomly on Grubhub! Ordered an extra set of fries because didn't realize tha
Came across this place randomly on Grubhub! Ordered an extra set of fries because didn't realize that my sandwich came with fries already! Very good prices for all the food! The sandwich was great! The patio looked cute as well.
Clare C. via yelp.com - Apr 15, 2021
The food was awesome! We had the ribs at 9pm (they close at 10) and the service was excellent!! Madd
The food was awesome! We had the ribs at 9pm (they close at 10) and the service was excellent!! Maddie provided exceptional service and was so very pleasant!!! Tim was a wonderful bartender and did not rush us at all!! The safety precautions were perfect too. Strongly recommend this place!! We were passing through and happy to come a ... read more
Chadwick T. via yelp.com - Apr 6, 2021
First time here . I had the fish and chips which was very good. Our waiter was very friendly and hel
First time here . I had the fish and chips which was very good. Our waiter was very friendly and helped us in choosing our wine and spent time talking to us . Had a nice patio with heaters tho we ate inside as it was alittle cool . Will go back again. My daughter had the prime rib sandwich was very good and large size.
Norma O. via yelp.com - Apr 3, 2021
I love their MAC and cheese it tasted delicious.
Naomi Lee via google.com - Mar 30, 2021
Reasonably priced, fun and friendly atmosphere. The wait staff and management were awesome. Nestled in the Brewery District downtown Columbus.
Kema Nutter via google.com - Mar 26, 2021
Ample serving portions; great cocktails; fabulous French onion soup; super friendly staff; one of the best kept secrets of W. German Village!
Paul Schunemann via google.com - Mar 16, 2021
I have been here a couple of times. And my first impression is how NICE they are every time !. So friendly and engaging you feel welcome. Food is always delicious. The ribs are tender, calamari, salads and amazing cocktails. I can’t wait for the patio to open up !
Dawn J via google.com - Mar 14, 2021
Nice atmosphere, food was decent if you're looking for a good sandwich, steak, salad. Portions were
Nice atmosphere, food was decent if you're looking for a good sandwich, steak, salad. Portions were large. Staff very friendly. A couple good options on the beer menu, however, it was somewhat of a weird selection to be paired with most of the meals. I feel like I would have enjoyed sitting at the bar or on the patio, but the booth w ... read more
Sara A. via yelp.com - Mar 7, 2021
The waitress done a great job, the food was good except the butter on my toast was gritty, so I told the cashier when she asked how everything was. She apologized and said she would tell them to change out the butter. All and all it was cleaner and better service at this location than it has been in well over the past year. We love g ... read more
Sharon Kris via google.com - Mar 2, 2021
It was amazing. They should warn customers that there is celery in the salad but even that didn't stop me from enjoying it ... read more
Natosha Massie via google.com - Feb 28, 2021
This was a great experience from wait staff and ambiance to the incredible food. The cheese steak eg
This was a great experience from wait staff and ambiance to the incredible food. The cheese steak egg rolls are a must. Great flavor, great presentation and really flavorful drizzle. We had someone get the prime rib special which was cooked perfectly with incredible flavor and the au jus was off the charts. We also had a perfect NY S ... read more
Don H. via yelp.com - Feb 27, 2021
I went with 2 of my friends and we absolutely loved dining here! The restaurant was beautiful and plenty of parking. I felt very covid safe. We really enjoyed our food! My 2 friends raved about the fish & chips! I loved my salad with chicken! The homemade dressing was very fresh & healthy. We had the best mozzarella sticks eve ... read more
Animal lover777 via google.com - Feb 26, 2021
Great food and great service! First time trying out Matt and Tony's and it was delicious! They are t
Great food and great service! First time trying out Matt and Tony's and it was delicious! They are taking covid precautions seriously and I really liked that !
Taylor B. via yelp.com - Feb 19, 2021
Great bloody marys at the bar, food was delicious. Glad they are back open. Bar experience was nice,
Great bloody marys at the bar, food was delicious. Glad they are back open. Bar experience was nice, bartender was friendly.
Darrek R. via yelp.com - Feb 19, 2021
Fantastic! After tasting what their chef can do with pork ribs I'm incredibly sad that Corona virus has put their ribeye supplier out of business...
scruffy 1 via google.com - Feb 12, 2021
Reviewing a 70th birthday party that included seven adults and two children for Sunday brunch. Absol
Reviewing a 70th birthday party that included seven adults and two children for Sunday brunch. Absolutely everything was wonderful. We had a number of small plates aka appetizers that we're outstanding. Followed by a number of dishes some that were divided in half because of the amount of food we'd already had, that were also very go ... read more
Kay T. via yelp.com - Feb 1, 2021
Oh boy - this was our first visit to this restaurant and definitely won't be out last! We came for r
Oh boy - this was our first visit to this restaurant and definitely won't be out last! We came for restaurant week based on a recommendation from local reviews. We were pleasantly surprised at the location and the hostess was super friendly when we walked in. When I see freshly make cheese sticks then thats what I am definitely getti ... read more
Joe M. via yelp.com - Jan 31, 2021
Hidden gem! You have to look for this place, it's a little off the beaten path but so worth it!!! Im
Hidden gem! You have to look for this place, it's a little off the beaten path but so worth it!!! Immediately entering it has a clean, urban vibe, upscale but also a place you could let loose for happy hour. COVID protocol was outstanding, made me feel very safe! Our server was so sweet. The food!!!! I had the grilled chicken salad, ... read more
Halley Q. via yelp.com - Jan 16, 2021
We have always had a wonderful experience eating here. And recently in the midst of the pandemic have been able to safely enjoy a meal out. Every precaution is taken. The food is always delicious and the staff super friendly. I look forward to our next meal there.
DR Martin via google.com - Jan 13, 2021
What a hidden gem! Absolutely wonderful dinner from start to finish! Justin is a excellent server and treated us so we'll! We had wings and they were amazing! Spinach dip was so good! Mozzarella cheese sticks were huge and wonderful! Our Prime Rib was so perfectly prepared and flavorful oh my gosh! Baked potato cooked perfectly and t ... read more
Jim Weaver via google.com - Jan 10, 2021
Great experience like no other since Covid. Excellent service, food and cocktails were superb. A place everyone should visit.
Kirstin Kiki Gibson via google.com - Jan 9, 2021
Love everything about this restaurant. I've been 3 times and I'll be back. The calamari is always go
Love everything about this restaurant. I've been 3 times and I'll be back. The calamari is always good and the cheese egg rolls ... read more
Lashunda D. via yelp.com - Jan 3, 2021
First time customer here. Heard reviews from friends. Their remarks are true.. Excellant service. Food portions and quality amazing. I definitely would go to this restaurant again. Thanks!
Al Johnson via google.com - Dec 26, 2020
Great food at this place well worth a visit 👌 ... read more
Stephen tierney via google.com - Dec 23, 2020
Great food, great bartender, friendly ... read more
Patty Sipe via google.com - Dec 17, 2020
Excellent food and a great brunch menu. Nice staff too.
Bill Parsley via google.com - Dec 13, 2020
Ordered from uber eats and was very impressed, the French dip was amazing and the chocolate cake was incredible, will definitely be ordering again ... read more
Nathan VanRooy via google.com - Dec 7, 2020
Back again last night. Cocktails, more chocolate cake, Justin again as server (he's awesome!), burge
Back again last night. Cocktails, more chocolate cake, Justin again as server (he's awesome!), burgers and filet. Yummy, safe, socially distanced, temps taken and contact info required. We feel safe dining here during pandemic. Food and drinks fantastic again!
JoAnn P. via yelp.com - Nov 28, 2020
We tried the Thanksgiving carry out dinner for 4, and it was the absolute best Thanksgiving dinner w
We tried the Thanksgiving carry out dinner for 4, and it was the absolute best Thanksgiving dinner we've ever had. Will definitely be partaking in this food frequently.
Jennifer B. via yelp.com - Nov 27, 2020
Very very good food and welcoming oweners. Our service was great. Would come again for sure.
Joud A via google.com - Nov 21, 2020
Best restaurant in Columbus hands down! Anything I order is just perfection every time didn’t know a restaurant could run this good in Columbus! I usually never ever leave reviews especially positive ones but I had to for this place ... read more
stayy Relevant via google.com - Nov 21, 2020
Lol, Flipline Studio's develepors are named "Matt" and "Tony", they make restaurant games, interesting if they owned a restaurant :DDD ... read more
Emerald Rhino via google.com - Nov 20, 2020
We live very close and visit this restaurant often. There are so many great dishes on the menu and w
We live very close and visit this restaurant often. There are so many great dishes on the menu and we like all of the ones we've tried so far. We order the burger and fries for carry out almost weekly. The habanero chicken is close to being great but the last couple I've ordered were a little too deep fried for my taste and I wish th ... read more
Gary S. via yelp.com - Nov 13, 2020
I haven't had salmon cooked this good in a very long time. Delicious! Delivered via DoorDash ... read more
Kim Sycks via google.com - Nov 12, 2020
Wow! All I can say it’s this place is a MUST! If you live in Columbus or are exploring Columbus. Food was incredible 20/10. Justin was our waiter, and he was FANTASTIC. He had such an amazing personality, and brought smiles on our faces. I definitely will request to be seated in his section next time we come for a date night ... read more
Tejah Taylor via google.com - Nov 7, 2020
So I went to Matt and Tony's again tonight. Had chicken, the Philly cheesesteak Egg-rolls, mushroom
So I went to Matt and Tony's again tonight. Had chicken, the Philly cheesesteak Egg-rolls, mushroom soup, and homemade macaroni and cheese. I forgot to take a picture of all of it, it was beautiful. The mushroom soup was the best soup I've ever had in my life. I sat on the patio with my dog and my husband and they are always accommod ... read more
Stacy C. via yelp.com - Oct 31, 2020
I'm late on reviewing but had to rave about this place! Wonderful service and great food. Had dinner
I'm late on reviewing but had to rave about this place! Wonderful service and great food. Had dinner with a group of friends from work and we had a great experience. Matt even stopped by our table to introduce himself and make sure we were happy with our food. He won us over with that alone! Go and enjoy!
Pam H. via yelp.com - Oct 29, 2020
Meet with some friends for happy hour...had a yummy peach martini and a hummus crudite platter...best hummus I think I've ever had. Never disappointed and our waiter Justin was funny and awesome.
Pam Cole via google.com - Oct 27, 2020
I enjoyed everything about this place. The bar staff was very friendly and speedy. I ordered mozzare
I enjoyed everything about this place. The bar staff was very friendly and speedy. I ordered mozzarella sticks for an appetizer, and the salmon for my entree everything was pretty on point in my opinion, I ordered Mac n cheese as a side and mashed potatoes both were good the mashed potatoes could've used a little more salt and the sa ... read more
Myesha J. via yelp.com - Oct 23, 2020
Apps and drinks were good but steak 🥩 needed A1 if you know what I mean ... read more
Brandon Boyd via google.com - Oct 19, 2020
Food we amazing. Loved the sauce that came with the calamari ... read more
Will Hinton via google.com - Oct 18, 2020
Omg i don't know how to put in words how freaking good there food is definitely going back this weekend.
Kaleena Daniel via google.com - Oct 18, 2020
They were on top of the Covid regulations with temp checks . The atmosphere was very nice . Our waiter Jeffery was Amazing with staying on service without rushing us. The food was Absolutely AMAZING !!! Everything was fresh and top quality. The cheese sticks were huge and the fresh made sauce was delicious! The Ribs were to die for !
Sharon Norris via google.com - Oct 15, 2020
The service and food was amazing! The slow cooked bbq ribs were soo good and tender!
Charde Harris via google.com - Oct 11, 2020
The service and food was amazing! The slow cooked bbq ribs were soo good and tender!
Tianna via google.com - Oct 11, 2020
Loved it...the drinks and the 2 appetizers I had were amazing!
Michael Wihl via google.com - Oct 10, 2020
Love the environment, service, and food! Consistently a great place. Lots of variety. Quality of food is very good for price. Portions are nice as well.
Scott Pittman via google.com - Oct 8, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire