skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Great classic American food! We got delivery a month ago and it was solid.
Victoria Goodwin via google.com - Jul 12, 2020
I ordered the burger with fries ...
I ordered the burger with fries on Uber Eats and wow! I couldn't be more impressed. I worried the fries would arrive soft and soggy but they were still crisp and very fresh!
Tamera L. via yelp.com - Jun 15, 2020
I’ve never tried Grub Hub and I randomly selected Matt & Tony’s at home. My wife and I had the Chimi burger and buffalo wings, and my wife ordered the mozzarella sticks , tater tots , and loaded tots . This food was a 10/10. It is the best bar n grill food I’ve ever had!
Drew Trotter via google.com - Apr 29, 2020
Been living in Columbus now for nearly 2 years and this is by far the best burger experience I have had. Will definitely come again!
kayla verhoff via google.com - Apr 4, 2020
I've been to Matt and Tony's twice ...
I've been to Matt and Tony's twice now, both times just before catching a show at Shadowbox Live. Overall my group has all enjoyed their food and the service has been decent. Both visits I ordered salads, which are huge and full of great ingredients! I really enjoy the salad with chicken tenders, as well as the Mac and cheese. The on ... read more
Jennifer M. via yelp.com - Mar 26, 2020
Always have a great time sitting at the bar. Delicious food.
Larry Wolfe via google.com - Mar 22, 2020
Great bloody Mary's and great food. See you when you open again soon ... read more
Darrek Robertson via google.com - Mar 19, 2020
Liked it well ... read more
juanita stevens via google.com - Mar 12, 2020
Great place! Modern decor, great view from the bar and the staff are excellent. We had a guest arrive late but the host had his dish out as soon as he arrived. Exceptional. Food is great and the drink menu is spot on. Recommended.
Brian Mercer via google.com - Mar 8, 2020
Good food and great service.
Gary Stevens via google.com - Mar 8, 2020
Really good food and the owners are amazing. ALSO, they are doing delivery now, through all the delivery apps. Go get it guys ... read more
olsi cobo via google.com - Mar 6, 2020
Prime Rib was delicious and veal ...
Prime Rib was delicious and veal parm was so good I just couldn't stop eating. Great place for a Friday night.
Tracy M. via yelp.com - Mar 6, 2020
Great hidden location with delicious food and the best macaroni and cheese I have had in Columbus. Our waiter was awesome ... read more
John DeSantis via google.com - Mar 4, 2020
The roasted beet pecan salad was very delicious. The habanero chicken sandwich was pretty good but could have been spicier. Great atmosphere and great service ... read more
Bill Kilbey via google.com - Mar 4, 2020
We stopped in for brunch and enjoyed the atmosphere and food. This is a unique location with a menu to match. I had a grilled chicken sandwich with the best mac and cheese I have had north of the Mason-Dickson line. Our waiter was top notch.
John DeSantis via google.com - Mar 3, 2020
This was my 2nd visit.  Excellent ...
This was my 2nd visit.  Excellent food and service both times.  Last night I had the prime rib, scalloped potatoes and broccoli; everything was delicious.  My friends had fish & chips, the ribs, the filet, and veal parmesan.  Everyone said their food was wonderful.  We all shared the HUGE chocolate cake (birthday celebration), and it ... read more
Lori W. via yelp.com - Mar 1, 2020
We ate at the bar, had our appetizers ...
We ate at the bar, had our appetizers, entree, and everything with in 20 minutes! The waitress was so nice!! The calamari melts in your mouth, the best i've ever had!! You get a crap ton of food for $15 when you order the fish and chips! And my boyfriend got the ribs ( a full slab and a half) for only $23!!
Maggie W. via yelp.com - Feb 29, 2020
The food, service and atmosphere here is excellent!
Tieonne Yvonne via google.com - Feb 29, 2020
Great place to eat !!!!! Great ...
Great place to eat !!!!! Great parking !!! Menu is diverse and complex. Chef knows what he is doing . Lots of choices. Need to try this place if you are a foodie.
D H. via yelp.com - Feb 22, 2020
Good food with good prices, my waiter Ronnie and his boss were great. Thanks keep up the Good Work, America love small businesses which makes a America Great!!!!!
Jorge Nunez via google.com - Feb 17, 2020
What a wonderful restaurant. The ...
What a wonderful restaurant. The setting is comfortable, waiting staff is friendly, communicative, and knows all the details of the menu. I arrived around 6 pm and was seated promptly (as requested) away from the happy hour crowd at the bar.

I started with lightly breaded calamari, followed by a tasty tomato mozzarella (burrat
... read more
Peter W. via yelp.com - Feb 16, 2020
Checked out this place in the old ...
Checked out this place in the old CBC spot. My boyfriend does Keto and I eat all his extra carbs so sometimes it's difficult to find a place for both of us. He had driven by the location (behind the German Village Kroger) and saw that it was open so we decided to check it out. We were able to get a table right away and our server was ... read more
Leah A. via yelp.com - Feb 14, 2020
Food was delicious and staff was friendly from beginning to end! Our two toddlers got the chicken tenders and fries and my boys loved the chicken tenders - they were seasoned and cooked perfectly! I had the Baked Trout - Crab stufffed baked trout with risotto & fresh vegetables, it was huge and delicious! I took home the leftovers! M ... read more
Daniel and Lynna Gehman via google.com - Feb 14, 2020
The prime rib lunch special was ...
The prime rib lunch special was to die for, so tender and all of the accoutrements to boot. The service was fast and personable and for the quality of meal that I enjoyed the price could not be beat. A great place to bring a business lunch!
Dustin M. via yelp.com - Feb 13, 2020
The interior hasn't been changed ...
The interior hasn't been changed much from the space's previous existence as CBC, which is great because the layout allows a lot of intimate seating options. The ambiance here is just lovely for a date night or showing out-of-towners a little secret nook in our city.

We both selected fish (salmon and trout) and found them to
... read more
Colleen R. via yelp.com - Feb 13, 2020
Great Place, Great Food !!!
Gus Peters via google.com - Feb 10, 2020
Very nice joint to go to before a Columbus blue jackets game.
Nick L via google.com - Feb 9, 2020
My fiancé and I have been to Matt and Tony’s about 5 or 6 times now. We normally have a sit-down meal. We aren’t really into sitting at a bar, so I can’t speak for that experience. When we go, we get an appetizer, main course (obviously), and drinks. Sometimes I get a dessert. No matter what we have ordered, the food was amazing. Tho ... read more
Elizabeth Waxter via google.com - Feb 8, 2020
Food was seasoned well & presented with class. Staff was attentive.
Brenda S via google.com - Feb 4, 2020
Great good. Great service. Definitely going back!
Ann Weidenbenner via google.com - Feb 3, 2020
Matt and Tony's was great! I had ...
Matt and Tony's was great! I had the rack of lamb *phone died before I could get a photo* it was cooked to perfection and flavorful. I chose scalloped potatoes and salad as sides. SN the thousand island house dressing whew ! . The blueberry cucumber mint margarita was tasty, refreshing and strong. The drink puts you in the mind of a ... read more
Adrionna K. via yelp.com - Feb 1, 2020
Service and food were both awesome! Need to tone the music down just a bit.
Alice Marshall via google.com - Feb 1, 2020
My first time here. Apparently it just opened. Went with the COO, CFO, and VP of the company I work for. Great service from Martina. Remembered my water no ice. Made two recommendations for me and I tried the jambalaya pasta as lunch and boy o boy was it yummy. Wish it was offered on more than Wednesday.
Justin Davis via google.com - Jan 29, 2020
Great Saturday night with friends ...
Great Saturday night with friends at Matt and Tony's. Warm greeting at the door with acknowledgement of our upcoming reservation. We waited in the bar and almost stayed there for dinner.  The staff was so friendly and attentive we  did not want to leave her!
We were not surprised when the wait staff was just as friendly. Kept our
... read more
J K. via yelp.com - Jan 27, 2020
I highly recommend Matt and Tony's! ...
I highly recommend Matt and Tony's! The service is impeccable. Karen took excellent care of us and the managers are very involved in your experience being a good one.

The menu has options for any pallet and the pricing is reasonable. The drink list is extensive and I always find myself ordering new things every time I come. I
... read more
Mary T. via yelp.com - Jan 25, 2020
Really great food with great prices! We went for lunch and everything was of great quality. We talked with Matt and he mentioned they don't even have a freezer and it definitely shows. I had the Po Boy a few people got the French dip and one person got the burger and we had no complaints. Looking forward to going back for dinner! I'd ... read more
Justin Giaimo via google.com - Jan 24, 2020
Went for restaurant week to try ...
Went for restaurant week to try MT out.  WOW!!  Great food and outstanding service.  Karen took care of us, and she was awesome.
Regular menu pricing is very reasonable.
This is a little hidden gem.
Bob R. via yelp.com - Jan 23, 2020
Delicious!
Margaret Baker via google.com - Jan 23, 2020
We've been here twice now. Once ...
We've been here twice now. Once with a large group and once with another couple. It was amazing both times. Great customer service and delicious food.
Carine B. via yelp.com - Jan 21, 2020
Stopped by for lunch during restaurant week, Wow! This place checked all the right boxes, great food, friendly and knowledgeable staff, and relaxed atmosphere that weither your in jeans or a suit you'll feel comfortable. Drinks: I ordered a side car from the cocktail menu, it was made and presented perfectly and I'm always happy to ... read more
Brian Horrocks via google.com - Jan 20, 2020
Second time visiting.  First time ...
Second time visiting.  First time was good. Tonight was great.  The ribeye and baked potato are terrific.  The rest of the table loved the  fried chicken and the turkey special.  Service was great ... read more
Alice B. via yelp.com - Jan 19, 2020
The mozzarella sticks are amazing!! Rest of the meal was delicious and service was quick wonderful.
Kyle Oberster via google.com - Jan 18, 2020
First time here.  Absolutely fabulous ...
First time here.  Absolutely fabulous. Prime rib is highly recommended.  Trout was perfect.  My wife is a crab cake expert and  loved hers.
Ron C. via yelp.com - Jan 18, 2020
We had dinner here on Friday evening ...
We had dinner here on Friday evening and it was great!

We arrived to find that we had been here before, but it was then called the Columbus Brew Pub (or something like that) but the parking lot had been paved, which was a big deal.

The inside had been changed as well. We were led to our table and ordered a drink while
... read more
Jay P. via yelp.com - Jan 13, 2020
My dinner salad was good and a generous serving. The French onion soup was OK, not much cheese melted on it.
David Howard via google.com - Jan 13, 2020
Delicious food, and great service ...
Delicious food, and great service. The restaurant is nice and well maintained.
We had brunch and everything was served hot and well made. The prime rib hash entree was plentiful, cheesy and we'll seasoned. My husband's French dip was hearty and hot. The double fried french fries were perfectly crispy.
Shelly H. via yelp.com - Jan 12, 2020
Excellent food. The French fries were double fried and extra crunchy. Went for brunch. Had the beef hash. It was a Philly steak over red skins. Cheesy and delicious. Worth the drive!
Helly Shoes via google.com - Jan 12, 2020
Had dinner after a matinee show ...
Had dinner after a matinee show at The Palace Theater. They have a really nice beer and cocktail menu. Didn't have a chance to check the wine list but it looked fairly extensive. My Sidecar was well prepared. We started with Potato Soup and it was well-seasoned with chunks of potato that weren't mushy. My husband had the salmon and I ... read more
Kathy K. via yelp.com - Jan 11, 2020
Amazing food and atmosphere! Seriously I have only great things to say about this place!
Matthew Hickman via google.com - Jan 11, 2020
A co-worker and I went for lunch ...
A co-worker and I went for lunch. We came across this place in passing and decided to give it a try. We were greeted with the door open to us and friendly staff all waiting for the lunch crowd to begin. Everyone was extremely courteous and polite.  Service was fast, served hot, and delicious. Both of us had the BBQ burger and fries. ... read more
Heidi C. via yelp.com - Jan 10, 2020
Steak was excellent, service amazing and love the atmosphere.
Steve Thompson via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
The staff was friendly, the service was the best, and the food was delicious.
James Dragani via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
Met some friends for an early dinner ...
Met some friends for an early dinner today and the food was fantastic. My Prime Rib was as expected, but my friend's steak was perfection.
Service was great and even though they've only been open for a short time - I'll definitely be back!
Sam M. via yelp.com - Jan 4, 2020
The meal was delicious. We went there for a family dinner. Good food and good company.
Mark Lowe via google.com - Jan 1, 2020
Love this place. We get the French ...
Love this place. We get the French Onion soup because it's super rich. Our go-to is the chicken tender plate with all the sauces. The portion is huge and the fries are those fresh cut kind you usually get at the fair. My husband has had the French tip which he loves. The fish and chips so good. We want to try the ribs but hate to swa ... read more
Annie W. via yelp.com - Jan 1, 2020
So far I've only tried the burgers but my co-workers have explored the menu more and join me for lunch whenever they get the chance. Great parking. Friendly staff. Hard to beat in the neighborhood.
Mark Noble via google.com - Dec 31, 2019
Great food with good service. Definitely a great place for comfort food. I had the fish and chips. Fish was a delicious fresh cod. The only thing I would have changed was the tartar sauce, which is actually a spicy remoulade...a little to spicy for my palate. My wife had the Osso Bucco served on mashed potatoes. We both agreed t ... read more
Irene Haerr via google.com - Dec 28, 2019
Great food at a great price ... read more
Nate Brotzki via google.com - Dec 28, 2019
Beyond Excellent food & service! Will be back!
Michelle J via google.com - Dec 25, 2019
I have been there twice so far, and both were for lunch. First time I had the habanero chicken sandwich with a side of the fresh cut fries and it was phenomenal. The second time we had the chimichurri Burger with the Israeli couscous and we also had the French dip with a side of mac and cheese. Both sandwiches exceeded our expectati ... read more
Jeff Rush via google.com - Dec 23, 2019
BBQ Burger was the best burger I have ever had. Fries were awesome. Definitely worth the trip. My new favorite lunch place downtown.
Glenn Fugitt via google.com - Dec 18, 2019
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire