skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Over all pretty good. Fries were kind of limp. Companions chicken sandwich was flat and dry.
Bob Blevins via google.com - Jan 17, 2022
This place was excellent! Our server, Sarah, couldn't have been better. The service was great, the food was quick and it was delicious! We will be back; there are some other menu items we'd like to try.
Thomas McIntyre via google.com - Jan 17, 2022
Get the French Toast and Fried Potatoes with a side of cheese delicious and great customer service. Delicious!!! Tens!!! Tens!!! Clap 👏🏾 for the staff and the chef !!! Yes!!!!
Sir Kyle Lee via google.com - Jan 16, 2022
Good food and friendly staff! You won't be disappointed. I had the wood fired pork chops with brocco
Good food and friendly staff! You won't be disappointed. I had the wood fired pork chops with broccoli and mashed potatoes. All three were very good. Also had the fried mozzarella sticks which we were told are made in-house with fresh mozzarella. They were thick and cheesy and breaded just right.
Alan R. via yelp.com - Jan 11, 2022
Amazing food, but even better service. Carlos was very friendly and constantly checked on us.
Nana Yaa Amoh via google.com - Jan 8, 2022
Great food. I had the prime rib sandwich and my fiancé had the New York strip, It was so tender he c
Great food. I had the prime rib sandwich and my fiancé had the New York strip, It was so tender he cut it with the table knife! The prime rib was tender and flavorful au jus. We WILL be back!
Brian M. via yelp.com - Jan 8, 2022
Wow! We were dropping our OSU student back at school and chose to eat here based on reviews. It did
Wow! We were dropping our OSU student back at school and chose to eat here based on reviews. It did not disappoint. The food was really good - salad, French dip and caprese sandwich. They had a good beer selection. Our server Sarah was so attentive and friendly. I told her I would include her in the review because she was so good. Th ... read more
Maureen B. via yelp.com - Jan 7, 2022
For a place that I've only ordered delivery from, the food not only traveled very well, but it was a
For a place that I've only ordered delivery from, the food not only traveled very well, but it was absolutely delicious. I'm excited to actually visit the restaurant itself. You can order from the restaurant menu, or their specialized at home menu, and I've done both. First, with the at home menu, I did the burger and coney dog, and ... read more
Gus W. via yelp.com - Jan 7, 2022
Love this place, the food isn't anything crazy but it's done really well. And they have a ton of high quality side options which is why we choose to order here often. Great value. The ribs are a stand out...it is usually hit or miss at places that don't specialize in them but their recipe is really tasty, great texture and glaze. ... read more
Taylor Anderson via google.com - Jan 1, 2022
I was in Matt and Tonys last night when Jason M (who left 1 star review above ) who is full of crap,
I was in Matt and Tonys last night when Jason M (who left 1 star review above ) who is full of crap, started screaming at everyone in the restaurant. He ignored clearly posted signs requiring masks. As for his "medical" condition, I didn't see an O2 tank attached to him so I'm pretty sure he could have walked 20 ft wearing a mask to ... read more
May M. via yelp.com - Dec 30, 2021
Great service and food. Nice environment too. It was a bit pricy, but we had appetizers, drinks and desserts, so it was expected.
Nate Craumer via google.com - Dec 29, 2021
Just left Mat & Tonys. We had a wonderful evening and some laughs!! Ate at the bar. Had the French O
Just left Mat & Tonys. We had a wonderful evening and some laughs!! Ate at the bar. Had the French Onion soup (perfect) and rigatoni with spinach and alfredo sauce ....it was delicious!! Service was excellent from Maddie at the front desk to Christopher (manager on duty) to Michelle behind the bar. Good food, great atmosphere and the ... read more
Larry W. via yelp.com - Dec 29, 2021
Best chocolate cake! And mozzarella sticks :) Great staff and good food. We live near by and love th
Best chocolate cake! And mozzarella sticks :) Great staff and good food. We live near by and love the carry out.
Melissa M. via yelp.com - Dec 27, 2021
Really 4.5. Great service and nice to have a dinner location downtown where you can park! Apps we al
Really 4.5. Great service and nice to have a dinner location downtown where you can park! Apps we all great. Steak egg rolls, mozzarella sticks and spinach dip. A little different the typical and very fresh tasting. Mains were good. Prime rib, grouper, spaghetti /meatballs and salmon. All very tasty although the Grouper was a little ... read more
Matt M. via yelp.com - Dec 19, 2021
Great Food! Great atmosphere! Great service!! Awesome experience!
Robin Rexroad via google.com - Nov 23, 2021
Wow, what a great locally owned restaurant! My husband and I live not too far away and just tried th
Wow, what a great locally owned restaurant! My husband and I live not too far away and just tried this place and I feel like we've been missing out! The service was great with a cozy atmosphere, but the food was of course the main event. Not many places start you with homemade bread and a salad anymore, and the starter salad was uniq ... read more
Missy P. via yelp.com - Nov 18, 2021
The best prime french dip sandwich I have ever had. The wait staff was fantastic.
Betty Welch via google.com - Nov 17, 2021
Good ... read more
Rica Whitfield via google.com - Nov 16, 2021
Consistently great food and awesome service, from the wait staff to the bartender to the owner. Prime rib sandwich and ribs are our go-to's. Total side bonus that it's zero hassle parking. Thanks guys!
Lisa Barr via google.com - Nov 15, 2021
The food and drinks are always fantastic, and server, Sarah F, offers amazing service! Really upbeat and personable! She really makes it worth coming back ... read more
JT Lucas via google.com - Nov 14, 2021
My sisters friend said we had to try this brunch. It was her day off and it was our dads birthday so
My sisters friend said we had to try this brunch. It was her day off and it was our dads birthday so we brought the whole family. We were able to make reservations for 10 of us so that was awesome. Being downtown I was curious about the parking situation. Very pleasantly surprised to pull up and find that they have their own private ... read more
Amanda D. via yelp.com - Nov 7, 2021
Nice local place with fair value prices on good food.
Justin MCDONALD via google.com - Nov 6, 2021
A friend visited from out of town and we decided to try out Matt and Tony's, largely due to all of t
A friend visited from out of town and we decided to try out Matt and Tony's, largely due to all of the positive reviews on Yelp. This building used to be the Columbus Brewing Company, but CBC moved and Matt and Tony's took over in the fall of 2019. The inside was a bit smaller than I was expecting, but it was cozy and had dimmed ligh ... read more
Adam G. via yelp.com - Nov 5, 2021
We were passing through on the way home from a long trip and happened to be in the area when they op
We were passing through on the way home from a long trip and happened to be in the area when they opened. Despite being the first guests to arrive, everyone seemed ready for us. The mozzarella sticks were by far the best I've EVER had. I would recommend them to anyone. If you don't get the mozzarella sticks, you will regret it for th ... read more
Olivia L. via yelp.com - Nov 3, 2021
The best part about my visit was the atmosphere and how they swapped the propane tanks for the heaters outside. Was nice and toasty! Did not hear about happy hour until I asked, and my fiancé and I tried some of the signature cocktails instead. They were all fine, and we just decided to get appetizers. We weren’t the hungriest so I c ... read more
Randy Davis via google.com - Oct 29, 2021
Food was delicious and our server was wonderful. Fast, courteous, and came back to ask about refills.
Jacqueline Bates via google.com - Oct 12, 2021
Food was delicious and portions were huge. I was with a large group and our servers were also excellent & did a great job with such a big group.
Tracy S. via google.com - Oct 4, 2021
Best wings I've ever had. Best ribs I've ever had, so tender you can slide the bones out and eat the
Best wings I've ever had. Best ribs I've ever had, so tender you can slide the bones out and eat them with a fork. Amazing French onion soup. Had the calamari before and it was perfect. Also have had the roasted chicken and it was so tender and flavorful. Some of the best service I've ever had. Fantastic atmosphere for a date night. ... read more
Rider M. via yelp.com - Sep 28, 2021
Really cool atmosphere. Service was good and the food was great. Definitely will be back.
J Steece via google.com - Sep 25, 2021
We live across the street from Matt and Tony's & order take out frequently. Friendly service & delic
We live across the street from Matt and Tony's & order take out frequently. Friendly service & delicious food! IMO, the best cheeseburger in Columbus! My wife feels the same about their gigantic piece of chocolate cake! This review is making me hungry, & am thinking this is a good choice for dinner tonight!
Shannon H. via yelp.com - Sep 24, 2021
We went to Matt & Tony's tonight before heading to the Palace for a show. Our reservation was at 5:3
We went to Matt & Tony's tonight before heading to the Palace for a show. Our reservation was at 5:30. We didn't realize it was happy hour because we never eat so early! We had been to M&T pre-Covid several times and just fell in love. We brought friends this time, and they were blown away. Everything was outstanding and our server, ... read more
Bob R. via yelp.com - Sep 21, 2021
Always a good experience. Cocktails are awesome ... read more
David Grayson via google.com - Sep 20, 2021
We loved it. Great food with huge portions, super affordable kids menu and great service ... read more
Allie Strabala via google.com - Sep 19, 2021
My family and I came across this restaurant through Yelp. Our waitress was very attentive and our fo
My family and I came across this restaurant through Yelp. Our waitress was very attentive and our food and drinks were delicious. We will definitely come back for another meal.
Merrigrace M. via yelp.com - Sep 12, 2021
Came to visit Columbus and we were not disappointed. This food is AMAZING. Got the French Dip and Spaghetti and both were beautiful and delicious.
Haley Palicki via google.com - Sep 4, 2021
Fun open atmosphere on short st next to dog day care. Staff is friendly and informative, recommended cheese sticks which is definitely a must try. Salmon sandwich with bacon was good, and the French dip was tender and with au jus plus horseradish is a winner. Highly recommended!
Rob Asher via google.com - Aug 24, 2021
Amazing Place to Eat... Best Prime Rib on Friday Night's....The staff is amazing as well...
Brett Patterson via google.com - Aug 22, 2021
Tonight was better. Tried the caprese chicken sandwich. What a delightful sandwich. Great flavor and
Tonight was better. Tried the caprese chicken sandwich. What a delightful sandwich. Great flavor and creamed spinach is the was to go as well. They stepped up their game this time. I'll give them 2 snaps in a circle. U get it girl.
Cj C. via yelp.com - Aug 22, 2021
One of the best restaurants I've been to this year! The ribs were amazing. The food was housemaid an
One of the best restaurants I've been to this year! The ribs were amazing. The food was housemaid and tasted amazing our server mason was very kind! Would definitely go there again!
Malachi G. via yelp.com - Aug 22, 2021
Loved Matt and Tonys. Food was excellent. Drinks were great. Service was attentive and very friendly
Loved Matt and Tonys. Food was excellent. Drinks were great. Service was attentive and very friendly. They've done a great job redecorating the old Columbus Brewing Company location. We had appetizers for dinner. The cheesesteak egg rolls were awesome. The wings were delicious, and they were big and meaty. The beat salad was deliciou ... read more
Fred B. via yelp.com - Aug 22, 2021
Enjoyed a delicious Sunday night dinner with my family. We had the wood fired salmon, half rack of r
Enjoyed a delicious Sunday night dinner with my family. We had the wood fired salmon, half rack of ribs, and the chicken rigatoni with spinach and mushrooms. Everything was house made, fresh, and served with a pleasant smile by Mason. Value was a excellent also. Whole place perfectly clean and organized with Chris and David managing ... read more
Stephen G. via yelp.com - Aug 22, 2021
Food is great!
Che' Mathews via google.com - Aug 20, 2021
Beer was good and cold, food was excellent and the people were very friendly!
Mike Preston via google.com - Aug 20, 2021
We were blown away by the service and the delicious meal!!! We really enjoyed our time there and can
We were blown away by the service and the delicious meal!!! We really enjoyed our time there and can't wait to come back!!!
Wendy S. via yelp.com - Aug 19, 2021
The food was a cut above. I had ribs I would give them a 9 out of 10. Patio service was very good to
The food was a cut above. I had ribs I would give them a 9 out of 10. Patio service was very good to.
Don B. via yelp.com - Aug 16, 2021
I love beets and goat cheese. The fact that the beets and goat cheese came in a salad...BE STILL MY
I love beets and goat cheese. The fact that the beets and goat cheese came in a salad...BE STILL MY HEART! Super delicious. The server had so many great suggestions and complimented her Chef along the way.... All in all this was a marvelous experience and I can't wait to go back!!!
Wendy S. via yelp.com - Aug 15, 2021
First - Just wow. The staff is a nice mix of experienced and youngish and they are very attentive. S
First - Just wow. The staff is a nice mix of experienced and youngish and they are very attentive. Second - A few dishes will set a place apart from the rest. Items that distinguish the rare from the pack. One is French Dip. It's on the menu, so I ordered. I know i used it before but "Wow". Toasted roll, steak so tendered I barely ha ... read more
James S. via yelp.com - Aug 14, 2021
Tonight was a great night. We have the best server in house Andrea. If you want a server with person
Tonight was a great night. We have the best server in house Andrea. If you want a server with personality and great service ask for her. But if she is not there sit at the bar and have dinner with mich " Michelle". The host is kinda on the rude side. I feel like they need to make the staff a little younger to bring in more of the you ... read more
Cj C. via yelp.com - Aug 12, 2021
Excellent service and delicious meal. Atmosphere had a cool vibe. Highly recommend this restaurant.
John Kelly via google.com - Aug 8, 2021
Laid back atmosphere, wonderful service, food was amazing! I got the blackened grouper and it was delicious.
Kelsey Dean via google.com - Aug 8, 2021
Excellent food!!! Excellent service!!!
David Peters via google.com - Aug 6, 2021
Quiet dining area excellent food. Waitress very kind and courteous ... read more
Pray Daily! via google.com - Aug 2, 2021
Is 1 of the BEST RESTAURANT 👌 THAT I HAVE BEEN 2.. EVERYTHING WAS ON POINT!!!!
Charles Johnson Jr via google.com - Aug 1, 2021
We enjoyed our meal here. The food was good, the beer selection was well chosen and they were very friendly and helpful. They have a very nice patio and a great bar area.
Tod Bowen via google.com - Jul 31, 2021
They are struggling with help and it shows. The food wasn't its normal amazing self and the table service left a lot to be desired. We have eaten here multiple times before and always had excellent food and great service, hopefully this is just a passing wave and I'm not going to judge them on it. Now Hireing all positions!
Greg Thirtyacre III via google.com - Jul 27, 2021
First time @ Matt & Tony's, but it won't be the last. Bruch was excellent, as was the service. Solid value.
Todd Elliott via google.com - Jul 25, 2021
Some of the best carry out we have had in a loooooong time. French dip is DELISH, and carry's well.
Some of the best carry out we have had in a loooooong time. French dip is DELISH, and carry's well. We had both the chocolate cake as well as the carrot cake and both tickled the taste buds. Looking forward to dining in!
Teresa J. via yelp.com - Jul 24, 2021
Service was fantastic and the food as well. Relaxed outside in the patio area, enjoyed the calamari and smoked salmon. Highly recommend!
Gil Guedes via google.com - Jul 16, 2021
Off the beaten path with delicious food and great drinks .. our server Maddie was probably one of th
Off the beaten path with delicious food and great drinks .. our server Maddie was probably one of the sweetest servers I've ever had .. when told it was my bday she didn't even hesitate to get our table a free dessert with candles (key lime pie, also delicious) .. go here!
Kevin K. via yelp.com - Jul 16, 2021
Great management ... read more
Michael Jones via google.com - Jul 14, 2021
Great atmosphere, great food, great service, and great location. This place has everything. Except r
Great atmosphere, great food, great service, and great location. This place has everything. Except root beer. Definitely recommend you add that to your beverage menu.
Lane C. via yelp.com - Jul 11, 2021
Delicious as always.
Brad Henry via google.com - Jul 6, 2021
We had a reservation and were sat quickly with water out pretty immediately. Waitress was attentive. Salmon was a little burnt, but that happens on the thin part pretty regularly. The fried mozzarella sticks are prime time, hand made, not frozen and brought in. My boyfriend said "this is the best baked potato I've ever eaten." Would ... read more
Jenni Long via google.com - Jun 30, 2021
Quality Food. Highly recommend. Everything down to our salads with dinner was top notch, high quality, and well prepared. I couldn't criticize anything we ordered.
Cyrus Virus via google.com - Jun 27, 2021
Excellent food ... read more
Peter Dedominici via google.com - Jun 26, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire